Yup. EMGs sound best in a Les Paul, and running into an amp that is medium gain (JCM800's are NOT high gain beasts. That's why Zakk uses an Overdrive and EMGs).
If you want a pickup similar to EMGs check out:
DiMarzio D Activators. They're a bit bright, but they're amazing, especially for drop tunings.
BKP Painkillers: On the brighter side, but similar to an EMG in tone, but with passive life and response.
BKP Miracle Man: Similar to the Painkiller, and it will let you know your mistakes
BKP Aftermath: From what I've heard, this is the closest thing to an EMG that BKP makes. It's got more symmetrical windings than the other pickups for a tighter, more precise attack, and there is a crunchy low-midrange present in the tone that adds to its brutality. But from what I've heard, it REALLY rakes the natural tone of your guitar and supercharges it!
speedemon said:
I was in your shoes in May;
+1 Shinozuko
+1 Eyeball (sorry to everyone who loves JJs)
You seem to have found your other issues that are not amp related.
Pickup height will also effect sustain, along with string gauge, nut, bridge and setup.
Have fun!
This is also the truth. Higher action and lower pickups equal more sustain, but lower gain. High gain pickups are meant to drive a low-gain amp harder into distortion. Once we got higher gain amps, the high gain pickups became merely a selling point. Amps today have enough gainto use a PAF in a death metal setting, but the use of high output pickups with a high gain amp has created a signature "sound" that we metalheads now go for. Too many people are scared to experiment